In this episode, Surendra Varma, the founder and CEO of Emgage, shares insights into their journey of scaling from zero to 100 customers by offering virtual HR services alongside their HR software.
Here’s what you’ll discover in this insightful conversation:
- Introduction to Emgage: Get acquainted with Emgage, a virtual HR platform designed to cater to the needs of startups and MSMEs. Surendra Varma shares the company’s vision of simplifying HR management for growing organizations.
- Identifying Market Gaps: Learn how Emgage identified the challenges faced by startups and MSMEs in implementing traditional HRMS solutions due to lack of resources and expertise, leading to the inception of their holistic ecosystem approach.
- Product and Service Offering: Understand Emgage’s unique proposition of combining HR software with consulting services to provide end-to-end HR solutions. Discover how their platform assists clients in setting up HR departments, managing HR operations, and digitalizing HR processes.
- Customer Base and Revenue: Surendra reveals that Emgage has acquired close to 200 paying customers, with an average deal size ranging from $1,200 to $1,500 per year per customer. Emgage primarily targets organizations with around 20 to 25 employees facing HR management challenges.
- Sales and Growth Strategy: Explore Emgage’s sales approach, which involves a mix of inbound digital marketing efforts and outbound sales outreach. Learn about their short sales cycle of around two weeks and the importance of consultative selling in demonstrating value to potential customers.
- Customer Acquisition Channels: Discover how Emgage leverages digital presence, SEO, content marketing, and referrals to attract customers. Surendra discusses their focus on targeting startups and MSMEs in the Indian market due to its significant growth potential.
- Funding and Team Structure: Gain insights into Emgage’s funding journey, with an initial investment of $200,000 from angel investors. Learn about their team of 40 members, comprising experienced professionals in sales, tech, customer success, and HR services.
- Vision for the Future: Surendra shares Emgage’s vision of becoming a comprehensive HR ecosystem, offering solutions for all employee and employer-related challenges. The company aims to continue scaling its customer base and ARR, focusing on serving the zero to 500 employee segment.
Transcript
Hello, everyone.
2
:Welcome to the B2B SaaS podcast.
3
:I'm your host, Upendra Verma.
4
:And today we have Surendra with us.
5
:Surendra here is the founder and
CEO of a company called M Gage.
6
:Hey Surendra, welcome to the show.
7
:Surendra Varma: Thank you.
8
:Thank you for having me.
9
:So,
10
:Upendra Varma: Surendra, so
let's try to understand, right?
11
:So what M Gage does and right, why our
customers are willing to pay you money.
12
:Surendra Varma: uh, so engages basically.
13
:So how do we project is engages
basically a virtual HR platform.
14
:So, uh, so initially when we
started, we started with the
15
:vision of building HRMS platform.
16
:Uh, uh, and we realized that,
uh, you know, in, in, in
17
:very quick time saying that.
18
:Uh, the segment that we're actually
catering to which is startup and MSMEs,
19
:the biggest challenge that they had
in terms of implementing these HRMS
20
:problem because implementing HRMS
system because what happens is the
21
:data says that 70 percent of companies
don't even have HR departments.
22
:90 percent of HRMS implementation
fails because of the vulnerability
23
:of the HR resources and the
maturity of the HR resources are
24
:managing that implementation.
25
:And we saw a big, uh, Gap in terms of
what HR companies are doing versus what
26
:customers were looking, especially in the
startup and SME segment, we said that,
27
:why don't we kind of create an entire
ecosystem and, you know, help them right
28
:from, you know, in terms of setting up
them to get the right HR department to
29
:give them HR resources to manage their
HR and then ultimately digitalize Right.
30
:So, so, so what we do is we take the
entire the customer, uh, through the
31
:entire journey right from first stage in
terms of setting up the HR department to
32
:kind of help them in terms of, uh, giving
the virtual HR managers who are qualified
33
:HR managers to run their HR departments.
34
:And then, of course, everything
of this happens on the platform.
35
:So, so we kind of do things end to
end, uh, and that's what primarily,
36
:Upendra Varma: it's, it's software
and services packaged together that
37
:Surendra Varma: Correct.
38
:So, yeah.
39
:So, you know, somebody, when I
was talking to someone, uh, you
40
:know, they taught, they, they were
asking about what is SAS, right.
41
:And, and, and a lot of people say that
it is software as a services, right.
42
:And, uh, you know, what I realized
is hard time is in SAS, everything
43
:starts software, but ends with service.
44
:Right.
45
:So, so that is something which is
pretty hard to kind of, uh, understand
46
:and but, but what makes customer
to stick with you is the services
47
:at the end of the day, right?
48
:Of course, you will have to have a
great product to kind of serve some
49
:of them, some of your customers.
50
:But then what matters at the end of
the day, especially in the startup
51
:and MSME segment is, is the service.
52
:Upendra Varma: sell.
53
:So I want to deep dive a lot,
a lot, a lot into it, right?
54
:So I just want to understand how
this is all structured, but before
55
:that, I just want to get a sense of.
56
:Who you're primarily selling this
particular package to, right?
57
:So like, just talk about
your customer base, right?
58
:How many paying customers do
you have on your platform today?
59
:Surendra Varma: So we've got
close to 200 paying customers,
60
:Upendra Varma: And, and what
sort of customers are these?
61
:Like, and, and I'm just strictly
trying to understand, right?
62
:So what sort of deals
are we talking about?
63
:Right.
64
:So is it like a 10,
65
:Surendra Varma: Yeah, so no, so we are not
we are not that big in terms of deal size.
66
:Upendra Varma: 000
67
:Surendra Varma: Our average, you know,
deal size is is is I would say in terms
68
:of one customer average out, I would say
somewhere around:
69
:Yeah, per year with say employee
base of around say 20 people.
70
:Okay.
71
:Uh, so, so our ICP, I would say that,
you know, when I say my ideal customer
72
:profile is companies, which are say
around 20, 25 people organization.
73
:Right.
74
:They, they have validated their product
ideas, they validated their organization.
75
:Now they're at a scale where
they are looking, the, the
76
:founders are facing challenging
in terms of managing the people.
77
:They don't have any now hr.
78
:So far, the founders are managing the
HR and now they feel that now they wanna
79
:grow and they, they rob things in their
plate they cannot manage, and they're not
80
:expert in terms of managing HR is where
they, they probably, they're the kind
81
:of ideal customer for us, and then we
take them through the entire journey of.
82
:Setting up HR to kind of managing their
entire HR, freeing them up from the HR
83
:operational hassle from day to day so
that they can focus on business and we
84
:can become their HR arm or extended HR
85
:Upendra Varma: sense.
86
:Surendra Varma: arm to kind of
do everything on the platform.
87
:Upendra Varma: So help me understand
this for a typical thousand
88
:dollar deal that you would do
with your ideal customer, right?
89
:So how do you, you know, provide these
services or consulting services, right?
90
:So like how many people from your
team typically engage with them?
91
:Like, how does that resourcing work here?
92
:Surendra Varma: So what happens
is the biggest challenge, uh,
93
:uh, in HRC, a lot of times what
happens, startups and Amazon, we
94
:think that HR is a one person job.
95
:I'll give you a very typical
example of a marketing team.
96
:So if you want to create
a marketing team, right?
97
:Marketing Is a combination of multiple
skills, for example, you have to when you
98
:want to build a marketing team, you'll
have to kind of have a team of people
99
:who are expert in SEO, people who can do
graphic, people who can build website,
100
:people who can write content, right?
101
:People who can do
digital marketing, right?
102
:So these are all combination
of four or five skills.
103
:You cannot expect that one
person to do everything.
104
:Similarly, what happens is in HR, you
expect one person to do everything
105
:right, right from recruitment,
onboarding, managing payroll,
106
:compliances, employee engagement,
talent management, not possible,
107
:Upendra Varma: Yeah.
108
:Surendra Varma: right?
109
:And what we do is like what and how
we've been able to do it and you
110
:know, keep keep the entire service
offering at a very decent price so that
111
:it doesn't actually, you know, hit.
112
:Uh, SMEs and startups so that they
don't need to even, you know, think
113
:twice to kind of outsource this,
uh, is because we have kind of built
114
:up, you know, practices within the
organization saying that we have one
115
:team, which does onboarding, we have
one team, which basically does payroll.
116
:And then, so you have one.
117
:Uh, account manager or say we say
that virtual HR manager who is
118
:responsible to communicate with you.
119
:But in back end, there is a team which
does, which is actually, uh, you know,
120
:expert in doing what they do, right?
121
:So we have compliance expert,
we have payroll expert,
122
:Upendra Varma: Teams, you know,
specializing in those particular
123
:aspects and they're serving multiple
customers across their various use
124
:Surendra Varma: correct.
125
:And then of course, the tool helps us to
kind of, uh, reduce a lot of manual work
126
:Upendra Varma: And so can
I, can I, I'm just saying to
127
:get some numbers here, right?
128
:So how, like, how does
this arrangement work?
129
:Right.
130
:So like my question is like, for example,
a typical, you know, HR consultant
131
:that you have on your payroll, right?
132
:How many customers do
they typically serve?
133
:And I mean, just divide by total
customers, but you know, maybe the total
134
:number of people that just to get a
sense of, you know, how that's scaling.
135
:Well,
136
:Surendra Varma: correct.
137
:So, so ideally, how do we, so
rather than, you know, getting into
138
:a number of customers, we kind of
map it with the number of users.
139
:Right.
140
:So we say that we say that one,
uh, you know, a virtual HR manager
141
:should ideally handle anywhere
between 250 to 300 employees,
142
:uh, with one, uh, extended help.
143
:Right.
144
:And, and we ensure that, you know,
the, the ARPU, which is, uh, average
145
:revenue per user is decent enough
to, so that we at least have,
146
:you know, 60, 70 percent margins.
147
:Upendra Varma: That's, that's like
10 customers that I'm hearing, right?
148
:So two people working for like, if
your, that's, if your ideal customer is
149
:around, you know, 20, 25, you know, users
on your platform, like 10 customers.
150
:But this looks like, you know,
less of us consulting services.
151
:And it looks like more like a customer
success manager that I typically
152
:hear, you know, SaaS companies
have, like they have them, right?
153
:So, so what's, what's the
thought process for you, right.
154
:To sort of, you know, package this, you
know, software and services together.
155
:Like, and do you do, do you just sell
the software itself or you don't do that?
156
:Surendra Varma: No, we do.
157
:We do.
158
:We also sell softwares alone.
159
:Um, but we sell it to typically companies
where they have mature HR teams, right?
160
:Where we see that the HR is primarily
not very stable and things like that.
161
:We always push them to kind of have
services because we know that even if
162
:they buy product, they are not going to,
they will not be able to implement it.
163
:They will not be able
to get the ROI of it.
164
:So rather than they doing it, burning
their hands and we say that, you know.
165
:Upendra Varma: Yeah, I got the sense.
166
:Right.
167
:So I think you talked about that.
168
:Right.
169
:So can you just quantify like how
many people, like how many customers
170
:would just, you know, buy the
software aspect of it so that I
171
:could understand your focus here,
172
:Surendra Varma: yeah.
173
:So typically companies just 50 plus right
where they have one or two HR, you know,
174
:people on site would primarily look for
175
:Upendra Varma: what percentage
of them are they, you know,
176
:Surendra Varma: I would say out of 200,
I think 50 percent of them buy software
177
:only 50 percent buy with with services.
178
:Upendra Varma: Makes sense.
179
:. So now I want to move forward, right.
180
:So in terms of, you know, your, I think
we talked a lot about your customer base.
181
:Right.
182
:So just help me understand that.
183
:So where are you getting all of
these customers from strictly from
184
:a top of funnel growth perspective,
where are they discovering Engage?
185
:Surendra Varma: Right.
186
:So there are two aspects.
187
:One, of course, is we, we are our
digital presence is quite good.
188
:So we've been trying to kind of
get hold of how digitally we can,
189
:you know, probably be available
whenever somebody searching for HR
190
:outsourcing, HR consulting, HRMS or
solution for startup or founders.
191
:HR issues is we, we write a lot of
blogs, is something which is primarily,
192
:uh, there are certain keywords that we
probably would want to rank pretty well
193
:and we are ranking pretty well with
whether it is virtual HR, virtual HR
194
:services, virtual HR team and things
like that, uh, is, is one source.
195
:Of course, second is the referral model.
196
:Referral model, because now we have a
decent set of customers and, and this
197
:is the problem which is common, right?
198
:Everyone needs it.
199
:It's like an insurance, right?
200
:Everyone needs it.
201
:But.
202
:You know, a lot of people buy
it proactively, a lot of people
203
:wait for trigger, and there are
certain people who would never buy
204
:Upendra Varma: Yeah.
205
:Surendra Varma: Right?
206
:So, so, you know, that that's
how it works primarily.
207
:So, you know, every organization
has this problem, right?
208
:They want to solve it.
209
:A lot of people are not
aware how to solve it.
210
:So they go on Google and ask it and
probably they're going to probably
211
:be available whenever they're
looking for a customer reference.
212
:Yeah, I mean, you know, one of the
biggest thing that we are looking at is.
213
:Customer is referring big time and
you know, I think 20 percent of our
214
:business comes from customer reference.
215
:Um, and, and, and, and we are also trying
to create a lot of channels, uh, you know,
216
:like incubators where a lot of startup
comes in, a lot of funded startups are
217
:there, accelerator programs where you're
offering them discounted, uh, you know,
218
:service offerings where Uh, we can partner
and we can actually, you know, uh, get to
219
:a, you know, many startup being, you know,
we're part of those accelerator program
220
:or say startup ecosystem is, is what
primarily is the, uh, uh, is the idea.
221
:Upendra Varma: Got it.
222
:So like, I'll, I'll try to ask
a tough question here, right?
223
:So the past 12 months, right?
224
:So you mentioned, you know, three or
four channels that I'm hearing that SEO
225
:and content marketing referrals, right?
226
:And maybe you partnering with, you know,
accelerators and all of it, which one of
227
:them actually led to, you know, most of
your new growth over the past 12 months.
228
:Surendra Varma: So I think, uh, today
it is more of push sales, uh, is, is
229
:what my, my, my team is reaching out.
230
:So content and, and, uh, and
the outbound sales, right.
231
:As I told you, my, my.
232
:My 55, 60%, uh, business
comes from push sales,
233
:Upendra Varma: What do you mean by
234
:Surendra Varma: as I told you already,
235
:Upendra Varma: it's essentially
you reaching out to this
236
:cold customers and is it a
237
:Surendra Varma: uh, yes.
238
:So when I said, you know, so when, so
usually what happens when we talk and
239
:tell the customer to a customer, they
really love it, saying that this is what
240
:I needed, but uh, is it something that I
need it urgently because it's hr, right?
241
:It's not going to impact my business.
242
:Uh, you know, because
I've been managing so far.
243
:Right, so we'll have to push saying that
if you don't do it, you will not be able
244
:to scale up, you know, you'll be, you'll
still be doing manual things and you will
245
:probably be spending a lot of your time in
terms of doing operational then focusing
246
:on core is what we'll have to push.
247
:We'll have to make them aware
of these things and somebody who
248
:understands it probably buys it
but most of the time it is push
249
:Upendra Varma: Got it.
250
:Right.
251
:And then what about
the sales cycle, right?
252
:So, I mean, I'm assuming it's
a thousand dollar deal, right?
253
:How much, like what, what's a typical,
you know, sales cycle look like?
254
:How long
255
:Surendra Varma: or you will be
surprised saying that, uh, you
256
:know, our, our average sales
cycle is around maximum two weeks.
257
:Upendra Varma: two weeks and then
258
:Surendra Varma: if they're not
buying within, if they're not
259
:buying within three, two weeks,
it means they're not interested.
260
:Upendra Varma: Got it.
261
:And what happens during these two weeks?
262
:Right.
263
:So is it you, how do
you showcase your value?
264
:Surendra Varma: So there are two things.
265
:One is, of course, uh, uh, there's
a conversation which happens as a
266
:detailed demo, which happens is a
detailed product demo, which happens.
267
:Uh, and, and, and there are a lot
of free things that we offer saying
268
:that, you know, if you really want
to build policy, these are the free
269
:tools, tips that we probably offer.
270
:So we, so people, when we think that
they are not kind of interested,
271
:we start sending them certain.
272
:Thank you.
273
:free tips, free tools so that, you
know, so just to help them, right.
274
:So it's, it's more about consulting
sales, you know, primarily then, then
275
:going and pushing, because it's like,
if you don't feel that you have a need,
276
:you will ultimately not buying it.
277
:And even if you buy it, you'll
leave it beyond a point.
278
:Upendra Varma: Okay.
279
:And you are in fact
selling consulting, right?
280
:I think you can easily
demonstrate the value, right?
281
:And now it's going to be working with you.
282
:Got it.
283
:That makes a lot of sense, right?
284
:So, and then just help me
understand it where your customer
285
:base is primarily based out of.
286
:Surendra Varma: We're quite spread
across India, so we've been, we've
287
:been India focused as of now because
we see there's a huge potential, uh,
288
:the way the startup ecosystem and M
m E things are going in our country.
289
:Uh, I think, uh, you know, 40,
50% of your G D P is being driven
290
:by startup and M S M E, uh, and
they are the highest job creators.
291
:Right.
292
:So, and I'm pretty bullish
about the way things are growing
293
:and the way the ecosystem is
growing and getting mature is.
294
:You know, this is going to be one
of the largest, largest market
295
:when it comes to HR as a service.
296
:Upendra Varma: any plans to move to, you
know, us market or something like that?
297
:Because at this price point, right.
298
:I mean, if you can crack it, I mean,
it's going to be in that state.
299
:I mean, you could just
300
:Surendra Varma: Yeah, so even if we go
to the US, probably, yeah, so we even
301
:if you're going to US, this is not going
to be the price point, of course, right?
302
:So, but yeah, we are looking to get into
a market which is getting developed.
303
:So we have set, we have started some
of the partners, we have a couple
304
:of customers that we built up, we're
just trying, you know, because the
305
:US is a very mature market, right?
306
:Upendra Varma: Yeah.
307
:Surendra Varma: And their
expectation is very different.
308
:Now, when you are very mature, uh,
you don't need, uh, you know, uh,
309
:certain services like this, right?
310
:When you are not mature or when you
are not, you don't have skills and
311
:resources to kind of have these things.
312
:Uh, and, and when you are able to, and
India is, is, is a pretty difficult market
313
:to kind of, you know, because there's
no standardization when it comes to HR.
314
:US is pretty standard, right?
315
:So there you know that, you know, a one
plus one is going to be two, right here,
316
:India, you know, there are, there are
leaves policy, there are things like that,
317
:which is very, very customized, right?
318
:And people don't follow the
complies and things like that
319
:things are getting strict.
320
:Now everything is getting online.
321
:From a taxation perspective,
GST perspective.
322
:Now people have realized the
importance of being structured.
323
:Upendra Varma: Got it.
324
:And so as you talk
325
:Surendra Varma: there is a huge potential,
326
:Upendra Varma: Got it.
327
:Yeah.
328
:And then like best of luck
on that journey as well.
329
:Right.
330
:So, and let's talk about
that zero to one, right?
331
:How did it all start for you?
332
:I mean, I'm, I'm sure you didn't start
on day one and say, okay, I'm going
333
:to build a HRMS platform with, you
know, consulting services around that.
334
:Right.
335
:There must have been a story
on how you reached here.
336
:Right.
337
:So what's, what's that story?
338
:Did you just
339
:Surendra Varma: Correct.
340
:So I so
341
:Upendra Varma: of that?
342
:Surendra Varma: yeah, so I
started my background is I'm
343
:basically an HR professional.
344
:So work with a lot of midsize
growing organization and I've seen
345
:HR challenges getting multifolded
or evolving as the organization was.
346
:So when you are 50, the
problem is very different.
347
:When you're 100, the
problem is very different.
348
:When you're at 500, the problem
is very, very different.
349
:Right now.
350
:So HR also has to get evolved, get
mature to understand what are the
351
:business challenges and then probably
we'll be able to kind of Uh, create
352
:that ecosystem to help organization
to grow beyond a point, right?
353
:It goes in hand in hand, right?
354
:I mean, and then, you know, while using
a lot of HRMS system, I've realized that
355
:though there are a lot of HRMS players
in the market, this market is cluttered.
356
:Uh, there are so many players, but
what is missing is You know, in terms
357
:of so far, a lot of products have been
built by IT people and been sold to HR.
358
:Uh, it was never been looked at from
an HR perspective saying that what are
359
:the problems with HR people and how do
you solve that and make it very simple,
360
:don't make it so complicated, right?
361
:Uh, you know, uh, and
that is what we tried.
362
:So that's how it started.
363
:So I started with a recruitment
firm and then got into consulting.
364
:Started considering a
lot of, uh, companies.
365
:And then, you know, we were also
implementing a lot of other third
366
:party products because they were, uh,
you know, expecting us to implement
367
:and automate the HRMS process.
368
:Uh, and then we realized during the
process implementation that this is so
369
:Upendra Varma: so you had an
agency, successful agency, you know,
370
:before this and then you eventually
transitioned with, you know,
371
:Surendra Varma: Correct.
372
:So we initially started offering services.
373
:We realized that only service is
not going to help so that, you
374
:know, we started building platforms.
375
:Upendra Varma: Mhm.
376
:Got it.
377
:And then you
378
:Surendra Varma: That's how the journey
379
:Upendra Varma: And then, and I'm
assuming that's where you got
380
:your first few customers, right?
381
:Surendra Varma: Oh, yes, absolutely.
382
:Upendra Varma: Yeah.
383
:So have you raised any external
funding so far to build your company?
384
:Surendra Varma: We did.
385
:We did.
386
:So, you know, as I told you, like,
I was working as part of one of the
387
:tech company, which probably came
from 13 million to almost 200 million.
388
:And they're there.
389
:So one of the VPs, you know, from
that organization, and the CEO
390
:of the last organization is my
angel investors on board, right?
391
:And they're not just the angel investor,
they are also advisors, and they They
392
:advise us because they have, they have,
they've taken a journey of a company
393
:from say in 10 years from say 2 million
to almost, uh, you know, 100 million.
394
:Upendra Varma: and then how
much did you raise there?
395
:Surendra Varma: So it
was around, uh, 200 K.
396
:Upendra Varma: 200 million.
397
:Got it.
398
:And yeah, and whatever, talk
about the team today, right?
399
:How big of a team do you
have and what do they do?
400
:Surendra Varma: So the team size
is around currently 40 people.
401
:Uh, you know, and I, we've had
a pretty decent experience guys.
402
:So my sales is from a HR tech
background who comes with
403
:almost 14 plus years experience.
404
:My, my tech directories is from
a similar background where.
405
:He was working with Oracle
building similar h c m products.
406
:Uh, my customer success head
is almost 20 years experience.
407
:My HR practice team or HR services team,
uh, you know, the average experience is
408
:Upendra Varma: how many, how
many in that HR services team?
409
:Approximately
410
:Surendra Varma: We have around,
uh, 15 people in HR services
411
:Upendra Varma: That, that, that adds up.
412
:And then what's, what's the vision here?
413
:Right?
414
:So how do you get to, let's say, a hundred
k r r or 500 k r r and how, how soon are
415
:you, you know, anticipating to get there?
416
:Surendra Varma: right?
417
:So, so we are, we are just, we, we have
just become, uh, you know, uh, breakeven.
418
:The idea is to now raise the next
level of funds or to, you know,
419
:so, so growing set, two x three x.
420
:Is what has been we've been able to
do it so far now what we are looking
421
:at to grow say, at least a text and
x right and and and the vision is to
422
:kind of, uh, not approach as a company
only as a HR HRMS company, you want
423
:to build an ecosystem, we want to
play only in startup and MSME segment.
424
:So any company which is starting
from zero to 500 is what the journey
425
:that we're looking at is primarily
the the ICP that we're looking at.
426
:And we are looking to kind of build
an entire ecosystem saying that
427
:Anything or everything related
to employee or employer problem.
428
:Everything is available on the
platform as small as employer.
429
:So employer wants to offer, say,
mediclaim to or any extended help, right?
430
:Employees looking for, say, as small as
help in terms of finding a house or, or,
431
:or a school admission for their kids to,
to getting the loan and everything is
432
:going to be available on this platform.
433
:So we are looking to kind
of make it Thank you.
434
:As a holistic ecosystem, which
basically not only helps our
435
:organization to manage employees, but it
436
:helps to attract and should
become a differentiator see and
437
:get should be a differentiator in
organization, wherever they are
438
:implementing that's what my vision is.
439
:Upendra Varma: Got it.
440
:Thanks.
441
:Thanks for taking the time to talk to me.
442
:Hope you scale engaged to
much, much greater heights.
443
:Surendra Varma: Thank you so much
for having me I think it's pleasure,
444
:always pleasure to interact with you.
445
:Upendra Varma: Thank you.
446
:Thanks for watching the
B2B SAS Podcast channel.
447
:Please make sure to subscribe
to the channel here.